Suunto app Forum Suunto Community Forum
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Users
    • Groups
    • Register
    • Login

    Suunto 9 baro very low elevation gain vs other brands

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Suunto 9
    148 Posts 21 Posters 13.2k Views 20 Watching
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • cosme.costaC Online
      cosme.costa @sky-runner
      last edited by cosme.costa

      @sky-runner said in Suunto 9 baro very low elevation gain vs other brands:

      @Dimitrios-Kanellopoulos I watched my Garmin many times in real time trying to understand how it calculates total ascent. It looks like Garmin also uses 3 meter threshold, similar to Suunto. However Garmin still counts total ascent more accurately. The difference is that it uses the 3 meter threshold only initially when there is a change in vertical direction. After that the threshold seems to be smaller because I see the ascent changing in 3-5 ft increments (1-1.5 meter). Also Garmin always captures the last bit of ascent when running over top of the hill. It seems it analyzes the trend and understands that I started running downhill because it often adds the last few feet of ascent after I have already started running down.

      In contrast, Suunto 9 seems to be doing some sort of averaging of altitude over 5-10 seconds in addition to the threshold, which results in additional smoothing of extremes (the lowest and the highest points). With Suunto, I noticed that I had to stop and wait at a highest point for a bit for the last 10-15 feet (3-5 meters) to be captured, and if I ran without stopping it would often miss that last bit of ascent even if I was above the threshold.

      I agree that for most people it isn’t a big deal, and the whole issue is much less noticeable when moving slower, for example hiking. But I noticed it regularly enough to be bothered by it.

      Suunto is not adding altitude in increments of 3 m. I do not know the algorithm but not all ascents are multiple of 3 m, as an example: today ascent 73 m (not multiple of 3), yesterdays ascent 738 m (multiple of 3), another day 395 m (not multiple of 3). So I think that the 3 m threshold triggers the ascent counting but then the increments are calculated in another way.

      Dimitrios KanellopoulosD sky-runnerS 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 4
      • Dimitrios KanellopoulosD Offline
        Dimitrios Kanellopoulos Community Manager @cosme.costa
        last edited by Dimitrios Kanellopoulos

        @cosmecosta that is correct. We dont do 3m segments.

        You can climb 4m go down and that is 4m added to your ascent. You just have to “eventually” climb 3 meters in I think 3 minutes (or more) to be counted.

        Community Manager / Admin @Suunto
        Creator of Quantified-Self.io
        youtube.com/c/dimitrioskanellopoulos
        https://instagram.com/dimitrioskanellopoulos
        https://www.strava.com/athletes/7586105

        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
        • fazelF Offline
          fazel Bronze Member @Dimitrios Kanellopoulos
          last edited by

          @Dimitrios-Kanellopoulos does this algorithm account for horizontal velocity? I have the same sense as @sky-runner - I’m more likely to see differences when cycling then when running. Thanks!

          Dimitrios KanellopoulosD 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • Dimitrios KanellopoulosD Offline
            Dimitrios Kanellopoulos Community Manager @fazel
            last edited by

            @fazel yes. It does.

            Community Manager / Admin @Suunto
            Creator of Quantified-Self.io
            youtube.com/c/dimitrioskanellopoulos
            https://instagram.com/dimitrioskanellopoulos
            https://www.strava.com/athletes/7586105

            fazelF 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
            • fazelF Offline
              fazel Bronze Member @Dimitrios Kanellopoulos
              last edited by

              @Dimitrios-Kanellopoulos Thank you!

              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
              • sky-runnerS Offline
                sky-runner Silver Members @cosme.costa
                last edited by sky-runner

                @cosmecosta said in Suunto 9 baro very low elevation gain vs other brands:

                Suunto is not adding altitude in increments of 3 m. I do not know the algorithm but not all ascents are multiple of 3 m, as an example: today ascent 73 m (not multiple of 3),

                I spent a lot of time watching altitude and ascent fields together while running up and down. I actually have both altitude and ascent fields in feet which gives more precision. 3 meters or 10 feet is the threshold. The watch can increase the ascent by more than the threshold, but I’ve never ever seen it increasing ascent by less than that. Most commonly it adds 10-13 feet at a time, but sometimes more. Yes, the actual resolution is actually less than 1 meter. For example it may add 11 feet which is 3.35 meters. Furthermore once it has increased the ascent value, that seems to be a new baseline because it doesn’t change the ascent value again unless I go at least another 10 feet up.

                To give you an extreme example of how total ascent is counted, once I did tiny hill repeats because I ran in a very flat area and that was the best I could find. I did 30 repeats of 17 feet (5.2 m) each. That is about 500 ft total ascent. On the elevation graph in Movescount I could clearly see all 30 climbs and each was 17 (plus/minus 1) feet, which is clearly above the 10 feet threshold. Yet the watch had counted only about 300 ft of total ascent.

                As I said, that is an extreme example, but it does demonstrate the issue.

                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
                • OktanO Offline
                  Oktan
                  last edited by

                  This issue is the only one which annoying and disturbing me in this watch 😕

                  Suunto 9 Baro Titanium & Ambit 3 Peak

                  Dimitrios KanellopoulosD 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                  • Dimitrios KanellopoulosD Offline
                    Dimitrios Kanellopoulos Community Manager
                    last edited by Dimitrios Kanellopoulos

                    @sky-runner that is what I am talking about exactly. If you climb a hill and don’t spend let’s say about 1-3 seconds (stable altitude) on the top then the last 1-3meters might not be counted. Note: Vertical speed plays a role here for this to be triggered / used.

                    We have several data “tests” over races and workouts to validate this ain’t a big issue.

                    However this is there for a specific reason, to avoid wind gusts (sudden ascents that don’t last more than 1-3seconds) , rain drops, and your arm / clothing suddenly blocking the pressure holes thus registering ascent and descent.

                    We don’t do stuff just because we think they should work better. We do deep analysis on data to find the middle group to both create accuracy and avoid problems that the user is facing.

                    Additionally those parameters are tweaked for each sport mode.

                    I would like not to expose more internal technology if that is ok with you. Many things have changed there since start of 2020.

                    The user (OP) probably doesn’t have have this specific issue I think

                    P.S. There is still one improvement not done and that is latch logic you had described. The reason for that is that as stated above, we cannot change something , without first having a strong RD plan / resource investment

                    Community Manager / Admin @Suunto
                    Creator of Quantified-Self.io
                    youtube.com/c/dimitrioskanellopoulos
                    https://instagram.com/dimitrioskanellopoulos
                    https://www.strava.com/athletes/7586105

                    surfboomerangS 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 6
                    • Dimitrios KanellopoulosD Offline
                      Dimitrios Kanellopoulos Community Manager @Oktan
                      last edited by

                      @Oktan Did you do some analysis on your claim ?

                      Would you like me Todo it ? Links and examples please

                      Community Manager / Admin @Suunto
                      Creator of Quantified-Self.io
                      youtube.com/c/dimitrioskanellopoulos
                      https://instagram.com/dimitrioskanellopoulos
                      https://www.strava.com/athletes/7586105

                      OktanO 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                      • OktanO Offline
                        Oktan @Dimitrios Kanellopoulos
                        last edited by

                        @Dimitrios-Kanellopoulos I registered to Runalyze and loaded the activity there. I’m a simple user and dont undestand what to do next or how to anylize or understand the numbers there, sorry.
                        I attached the activity a few messages above (https://www.strava.com/activities/4486972002), so if you can test it, it would be great. If you need the gpx from Strava, I can maybe attach it here also.

                        BTW, I looked today at other ride, 73 km long, which I did at 2019 with Ambit 3 Peak, and the same ride this year, 2020, with S9B.
                        Ambit logged elevation gain of 1491 m (https://www.strava.com/activities/2101913528)
                        S9B logged elevation gain of 1284 m (https://www.strava.com/activities/3138457224)

                        Suunto 9 Baro Titanium & Ambit 3 Peak

                        Dimitrios KanellopoulosD cosme.costaC 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 0
                        • Dimitrios KanellopoulosD Offline
                          Dimitrios Kanellopoulos Community Manager @Oktan
                          last edited by

                          @Oktan can you pm me the suunto app links or fit files so I can analyse this?

                          I would prefer 1 activity to start with with a format like this:

                          FIT File or suunto app link

                          • Expected ascent (ie what other services say)
                          • Registered ascent

                          Community Manager / Admin @Suunto
                          Creator of Quantified-Self.io
                          youtube.com/c/dimitrioskanellopoulos
                          https://instagram.com/dimitrioskanellopoulos
                          https://www.strava.com/athletes/7586105

                          OktanO 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                          • cosme.costaC Online
                            cosme.costa @Oktan
                            last edited by

                            @Oktan said in Suunto 9 baro very low elevation gain vs other brands:

                            BTW, I looked today at other ride, 73 km long, which I did at 2019 with Ambit 3 Peak, and the same ride this year, 2020, with S9B.
                            Ambit logged elevation gain of 1491 m (https://www.strava.com/activities/2101913528)
                            S9B logged elevation gain of 1284 m (https://www.strava.com/activities/3138457224)

                            No offense here but all the ascent values that are in Strava when they are pushed from Movescount are not reliable because is not what the watch registered, this ascent is corrected by Strava. Strava only shows the watch ascent if it is pushed from SA. I understand that the activity with the A3 was uploaded using Movescount, have you checked the ascent value in Movescount for that activity?

                            Dimitrios KanellopoulosD pilleusP 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 1
                            • Dimitrios KanellopoulosD Offline
                              Dimitrios Kanellopoulos Community Manager @cosme.costa
                              last edited by

                              @cosmecosta correct. Movescount doesn’t push the ascent to Strava so Strava recalculates that

                              Community Manager / Admin @Suunto
                              Creator of Quantified-Self.io
                              youtube.com/c/dimitrioskanellopoulos
                              https://instagram.com/dimitrioskanellopoulos
                              https://www.strava.com/athletes/7586105

                              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                              • pilleusP Online
                                pilleus @cosme.costa
                                last edited by pilleus

                                @cosmecosta you can upload the gpx file manually to Strava. If there is the additional information “with Barometer” in the creator tag of the gpx file, Strava trusts the watch and shows the ascent of the watch and you can use the ascent from the A3 or change it to the ascent of Strava. If not, add it with an editor before uploading the file. A good way to compare watch and Strava data.

                                https://www.instagram.com/moves.are.life/
                                Suunto Vertical Black Lime
                                Suunto 9 Peak Pro Black
                                Suunto Spartan Ultra Stealth Titanium

                                cosme.costaC 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                • freeheelerF Offline
                                  freeheeler
                                  last edited by

                                  @sky-runner @Dimitrios-Kanellopoulos
                                  I see that we have a calculation that is not summing up for extreme conditions and hence might under calculate the total ascent. On the other hand I’m glad the watch does not count gusts or when I bent down to fiddle around with the buckles or the climbing bails…

                                  so it follows as usual the common rule of development: it is a compromise and all the developers can do is find the best compromise for the majority of athletes 👍

                                  If we’d let people tweak settings like that they would be disappointed due to propably wrong settings, too.
                                  I remember that QS has a function to filter a bit towards more or less sensitivity on that, please correct me if I’m wrong!
                                  I did not touch this setting as I think that Dimitrios as set it to a reasonable setup.

                                  living sideways

                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 5
                                  • surfboomerangS Offline
                                    surfboomerang @Dimitrios Kanellopoulos
                                    last edited by

                                    @Dimitrios-Kanellopoulos said in Suunto 9 baro very low elevation gain vs other brands:

                                    However this is there for a specific reason, to avoid wind gusts (sudden ascents that don’t last more than 1-3seconds) , rain drops, and your arm / clothing suddenly blocking the pressure holes thus registering ascent and descent.

                                    Wind does affect altitude a lot. Below a screenshot with a part of a windsurfing session. According to the data it would have been a bumpy ride 😄
                                    (To be honest, I have no idea why altitude is recorded for an activity type like windsurfing)

                                    bf38a4e0-3096-4d31-ab67-cc33c44d444e-image.png

                                    Suunto Vertical Titanium Solar
                                    OnePlus Nord 4

                                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                                    • cosme.costaC Online
                                      cosme.costa @pilleus
                                      last edited by cosme.costa

                                      @pilleus Thanks for the trick, but what I want to state is that sometimes people put a lot of trust in Strava when the values are wrong. Without any trick an uploaded activity from Movescount, the ascent in Strava doesn’t match the watch, so you can’t compare directly two activities in Strava, if one is pushed from MC and another from SA. Here @Oktan should compare the values from MC and the values from SA to seek discrepancies.

                                      I mean, I use Strava for the social part but I do not trust much the values, at least you have to be aware of the downsizes/tricks. As an example, today I did a trail run with very steep parts, that I had to walk, so Strava decided that I was under their threshold and has decided to improve my pace from the real one 5:26 min/km to 5:19 min/km, I know the trick that only doing a one second pause in the watch, then Strava shows the real pace. So, sometimes, when you see some values in strava they do not need to be correct.

                                      For me the only right values are the ones coming from the watch directly, knowing that an algorithm is an algorithm and can be tuned in different ways.

                                      pilleusP 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
                                      • pilleusP Online
                                        pilleus @cosme.costa
                                        last edited by pilleus

                                        @cosmecosta said in Suunto 9 baro very low elevation gain vs other brands:

                                        sometimes people put a lot of trust in Strava when the values are wrong.

                                        With my old Spartan Ultra I experienced for cycling activities no noteworthy differences between ascent of the watch and ascent of Strava’s GPS based ascent.

                                        I usually have 850 to 1000 meters of climbing on a distance of 35 km with the mountain bike. The difference is usually about 10 to 15 meters between SSU and Strava, if I use the option to use the ascent of Strava.

                                        https://www.instagram.com/moves.are.life/
                                        Suunto Vertical Black Lime
                                        Suunto 9 Peak Pro Black
                                        Suunto Spartan Ultra Stealth Titanium

                                        cosme.costaC 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                        • cosme.costaC Online
                                          cosme.costa @pilleus
                                          last edited by

                                          @pilleus Well mi experience is different, in trail running differences can be very big, more than one hundred meters in a 400 m ascent run.

                                          For the MTB, I’m using a dedicated barometric GPS that has always overrode the Strava correction, and Strava shows the GPS value but I have checked using Strava’s correction and:

                                          GPS: 803 m / Strava 766 m
                                          GPS: 697 m / Strava 635 m
                                          GPS: 711 m / Strava 630 m

                                          And this are 3 random activities that I checked.

                                          So…

                                          pilleusP 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                          • pilleusP Online
                                            pilleus @cosme.costa
                                            last edited by pilleus

                                            @cosmecosta I think the problem is the terrain. A GPS track 3 meters away from the path or street in steep and hilly terrain will cause a miscalculation of Strava’s GPS based data.

                                            And I experienced that my SSU is more accurate recording the ascent than my S9B.

                                            https://www.instagram.com/moves.are.life/
                                            Suunto Vertical Black Lime
                                            Suunto 9 Peak Pro Black
                                            Suunto Spartan Ultra Stealth Titanium

                                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 3
                                            • First post
                                              Last post

                                            Suunto Terms | Privacy Policy