Suunto vertical with significant added distance for walks
-
@André-Faria what did you mean by phone? I did not record my activity with phone.
i would say S9P’s GPS accuracy is still great except hiking under tropical rainforest especially during long hour activity. distance is even worst if i got stop and rest at the waterfall area. i guess waterfall is one of the factor affected the accuracy as well.
i did running in a city/residential area and trail running the distance difference is not much compared to SV. -
one still always remember (me first) how GPS is working : signal send from the space, with relative position of the satelite (with its error), time of data sent (with its error), everything is crossing space and atmosphere, loosing time in between (with some theorical corrections), potentially reflecting the water of the waterfall, the wall of the waterfall, the trees around (loosing time again), and trying to reach your watch, potentially with its antenna not well properly aligned with the skies.
Need at least four different signals to finally calculate (with errors) where you are expected to be.And potentially, every condition of all this (and i am surely not knowing a ten’s of all) is changing constantly.
-
Update. I reset my watch and did a run. And amazingly all 3 of my watches gave the exact same distance ! I scrutinised the tracks and found all 3 pretty close to one another with vertical probably the most accurate amongst the 3! Will continue to monitor and see if this improvement continues . Really happy now ! -
@leafs93 maybe I should reset my SV as well.
-
@Ilya-Sul I am not sure if this is one off. Will do more runs and walk and update again.
-
I realise that the adding of distance comes mainly from my walks, and I think somehow the Vertical picks up too much noises, and that is causing a straight line walk to be ziczac. This was just a short walk of approx 3km, but there is a good 120meters difference between my vertical and my 2 other watches. Both Apex 2 pro and Watch 8 gave identical distance btw.
-
@leafs93 Yes, the SV is not good at tracking slower activities (in my experience ofc). The tracks always come out looking horribly messy. I hope this improves with future releases as I bought the watch mainly for hiking.
-
@Ilya-Sul
i think different people with different experiences. maybe you need to try few more hike to judge?
i hike a lot with SV. for me SV accuracy are very good under challenging environment. although normally Coros watch are shown shorter distance but i doubt their accuracy. i notice sometimes at the curve route, Coros will show straight line instead of curve. that’s why their distance is shorter. -
@Ilya-Sul said in Suunto vertical with significant added distance for walks:
@leafs93 Yes, the SV is not good at tracking slower activities (in my experience ofc). The tracks always come out looking horribly messy. I hope this improves with future releases as I bought the watch mainly for hiking.
ooh bom, it’s not true, SV has very good gps accuracy (according to our great tester )at 16/km trail running.
-
@zhang965 this is becoming online harassment, and trust me, we get messages asking for you being banned from the forum.
-
@babychai I have logged about 70-80 walking and hiking activities in rather unchallenging environments and the tracks come out jagged, through buildings and gardens (unless, of course, all maps on Runalyze are wrong
) and overall pretty unsightly. My Garmin non-multiband! devices, such as my Epix 2, produce much better tracks. Even my S9PP isn’t as offset as my SV.And, afair, I said “in my experience ofc”.
-
@isazi said in Suunto vertical with significant added distance for walks:
@zhang965 this is becoming online harassment, and trust me, we get messages asking for you being banned from the forum.
For someone so quick to talk about GDPR, Mr Z. should be careful because french law is not nice to online harassers. I’m so fed up with this behavior, if the admins/mods don’t intervene, I’m quite tempted to send a report to PHAROS (https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/PHAROS).
-
@Ilya-Sul seems I am not the only who notice this that slower activities seem to add more distance to suunto watches compared to others, and that is due to tracks more ziczac instead of straight line… thanks for sharing this.
-
Can also confirm zig zagging in track on slow moving activities.
Cant say whether its actually adding extra distance but distance from route was meant to 26km and came out 28km.Some tracks fair better than others. Not sure if Suunto does any smarts to save power but some of the straighter sections of the routes seem to be polling the gps less often. Looks like nearly straight sections are approximated as a straight line with gps updating on sharper bends only.
Performance mode btw. -
It’s really interesting what problems there are. I cannot confirm the problem with my Vertical. Comparing with the Fenix 7X, I can see very small differences even in slow activities. If anything, the Vertical measures up being a few feet shorter for me.
-
@Ilya-Sul and @e6321 If you look at the information @zhang965 posted for my Trail Run (very slow on the way up and quite technical with some off trail and faster on the way down) you will see the tracks match quite well. This particular watch has field test firmware but I can repeat this with production firmware. And I am not a great tester, just a tester that likes Suunto much like all the other testers out there.
I will note that the lower part of this is in trees and the upper part is above treelined as you can see in the satellite overlay. Most of you would find this barely meets the definition of a trail; a lot of rocks, washed out and above treeline off trail and straight up a mountainside. However, I am not seeing the issue of track problems when moving slowly as was accurately noted by @zhang965.
I am not as fast as Killian J:)
-
@isazi said in Suunto vertical with significant added distance for walks:
@zhang965 this is becoming online harassment, and trust me, we get messages asking for you being banned from the forum.
Well he’s finally bought a Garmin, so I’m assuming their forum will inherit him soon