9pp OHR way off
-
@MILO83 Maybe the arm movement is still too much, but I’m not a badminton expert.
-
Ok, we’re swimming in the wrong direction
. I’ve been playing badminton for 15 years (winter season only) and no issues with OHR until a couple of weeks ago.
Had some strange readings with alpine skiing and hiking also.
Two or three times after the last update the OHR stopped recording completely (24/7 and activities). A restart solved it.
Something strange is happening… will keep testing.
And to be clear!!! I’m not looking for reasons to buy the Race!!
-
@MILO83 Next time it stops, check to see if the LEDs are flashing green. If so, it is a recording issue, happens to me from time to time too and I think cold related (low blood flow). If the LEDs are not flashing I would try a hard reset since a soft reset seems to help.
-
Hi all,
I did a factory reset and nothing changed.
Hiking is not that good even during the Summer but now it’s even worse.Last hiking after the reset:
Last badminton after the reset:
When hiking 9pp OHR always had problems when HR drops but not like this.
With badminton… no comment needed I guess.I compared my activity with a colleague who was wearing the Vertical and even his HR was totally off. Ok, could be the temperatures (just above 10 deg C I guess) but this is just unusable :(.
-
And another comparison. Same hill, similar pace, similar form.
9 Peak January 2022:
9 Peak Pro January 2023:
9 Peak Pro Today:
Can’t get a normal OHR reading for the past few weeks…
-
@MILO83 OHR can vary for me substantially. Best to compare on same run. Here are two examples of S9 Peak Pro OHR compared to a belt, both last week on the same firmware. One is great and one a poor match to the belt.
-
@Brad_Olwin at least you had one great one
!! I don’t expect the OHR to match the belt. I’m just saying I have been on Suunto OHR for a few years now and never experienced such constantly awful results. Will keep on testing. To bad I don’t have 2 watches for comparison. I have a belt though (if it’s still working). -
@MILO83 I don’t think anything has changed with OHR. Cold temperatures certainly makes it worse for me.
-
Having tried Garmin, Polar, Suunto and Fitbit, OHR on the last one is the closest that I’ve seen to a heart strap. I’m sure there are other people (including famous internet testers :)) that would disagree violently! I think that WHR is terribly specific to the person and how that person wears their watch.
-
@wakarimasen Not surprised as Fitbit is smaller and lighter and agree about individual variations.
-
Just as a bit of anecdotal information for this topic. I went out for a walk yesterday evening and logged it using my S9PP. During the walk, I noticed that the HR being shown seemed to be a bit ‘off’ compared to what I perceived to be correct. The watch was quote close to my wrist bone, and so I shifted it back a little. The result was much improved data, which I guess just shows how critical this placement is.
By the way, before anyone queries the ‘perception’ of what was correct, I was also wearing a Garmin 955 for comparison - I just didn’t want to mention it
