Steep counter

lilaceo

It is NOT accurate,
suggestion , (i don’t know it is possible) but would it be possible to program de watch so that if the speed (gps of the watch) is more than 8 km/h or less or = 0 km/h , STOP COUNTER.
in this way when you are driving or biking or seated at the sofa the watch doesn’t count any step,
what do you think ?

Tieutieu

@lilaceo Step counter is not based on GPS but on accelerometer / movements of the watch.
I personnaly don’t care if step counter is not totally accurate. It’s true that when diving as my wrist moves, the watch counts some steps.
Be by the end I see step counter only as a “motivationnal” way to help people to move. I really don’t care if counter of the day is at 4378 step while in “reality” I’ve made only 3926…

pilleus

The fact is that the 9PP and the Vertical count steps even if I don’t take any steps (arm movement is sufficient when I’m sitting at the PC or in the car or while I am cycling).

In my opinion, this is a poor implementation and interpretation of the data provided by the watches’ accelerometer and gyroscope.

If I want to record data, then it should be approximately correct.

I always have to smile when the big boys compare the watches in terms of GPS accuracy and describe every little corner that is not tracked accurately as “inaccurate”, when the watch can’t even measure steps accurately.

Other manufacturers can do that. And very accurately. And Suunto can actually do it too, if I take the 5PP as a comparison …

Zdeněk Hruška

@pilleus Maybe those big boys don’t think that steps are important and they don’t really care about exactly how many steps they did. But the GPS precision is important for them (if they talk about the GPS watch). Just a guess

pilleus

@Zdeněk-Hruška

That’s certainly the case, you’re right (by the way, the GPS watches of other manufacturers are also GPS watches). But when I consider that, for example, the distance on the treadmill is calculated based on the steps and even a GPS measurement can calibrate the number of steps, then the pedometer should only measure steps and not interpret every movement as a step. And what is with fused speed?

This is how everyday users see it and I’m certainly not the only one … because even a GPS watch will be used without GPS most of the time. At least for me.

Zdeněk Hruška

@pilleus Yes, you are right about the treadmill. That usually isn’t working. I had a luck several times that the distance from the watch was actually good while doing a treadmill workout. Maybe because now you can adjust the distance after the activity and maybe it does calibrate a watch somehow. But overall it’s not good.
I have a Stryd for that kind of workouts but usually connected to my phone as you can’t set an incline on the watch so the power is completely off while you are running uphill. I have hoped that there would be a Stryd SuuntoPlus app witch adjustable incline. Maybe some day… But still, for me it’s similar like with measuring heart rate - if you need a precise information there are external sensors for that. But I agree with that running on a tradmill case.
Anyway, having said that, I still think that the watch do a good job measuring steps. Because if I think about the use case for step counting - You just need to watch trends don’t you? And it does a good job for watching trends. I mean if I see 20 000 steps one day I know I moved quite a lot. And that’s what you need to know isn’t it? It’s not important if there are 17000 steps in reality what does it change? I can see that if I sit all day I have much less even if I move my arm and I get some faulty steps. In what scenario do you need to know the exact count of your steps?

pilleus

@Zdeněk-Hruška

Of course, it doesn’t matter how many steps I take every day. It also doesn’t matter how high the heart rate measured on my wrist is. And whether I have now covered 100 meters more or less with GPS.

Use a chest strap if you want accurate data. I read that again and again. Buy a Stryd if you’re interested in steps. Also like to write again and again.

And if you want emojis on your watch, then you’re one of the weird ones. I’ve read that too.

If I record data, I want it to be correct. And other manufacturers show that it works. That’s what it’s about and not about trends, whether I walked more today than yesterday. I know that even without a watch.

But I’m quiet again now and take a few steps in the fresh air … whether a few more or a few less.

Zdeněk Hruška

@pilleus But all of that what you hear is correct. There are more precise ways how to measure certain… measures
But I can tell you a difference between how important is to have for example precise HR and precise GPS versus steps counting - at least for a sports oriented watch. There are use cases for it you know. There are situations for which it matters to have a precise HR. There are also situations where it matters to have a precise GPS. We can find many examples. There isn’t any use case known to me where it matters to have precise steps count. You just want a perfect number just for a sake of it or am I wrong? How will you use that perfect number if you have it? Maybe I just don’t know I can be wrong I admit that. That’s why I am asking.
Enjoy your time outside:)

Dimitrios Kanellopoulos

threadmill distance is not calculated by steps only

pilleus

@Zdeněk-Hruška said in Steep counter:

You just want a perfect number just for a sake of it or am I wrong? How will you use that perfect number if you have it?

Many health insurance companies allow their members to participate in a bonus program via smartphone app. Proof of health-promoting measures (e.g. daily steps) can be uploaded to the app. The points are automatically collected and credited. Many bonus program apps can be linked to Google Fit. I synchronize my step data with Google Fit.

With the 9PP and the Vertical, I have more steps at my desk at lunchtime than with any other watch in the evening after a walk. Good for my rewards program, but in reality that’s fake data.

I actually don’t use the 9PP or Vertical for this because I’m a sportsman and fairness and comparability are paramount to me.

So it pays to use the better and more accurate measurement method, as you wrote so well.

pilleus

@Dimitrios-Kanellopoulos said in Steep counter:

threadmill distance is not calculated by steps only

With my 9PP I can record a treadmill workout while I am sitting in front of my pc and just move my arm up and down. So I assume that no step is required to calculate the distance on the treadmill.

You can try it and I think it will show, that this is not the perfect solution concerning “step counting”.

The step-counter is garbage. I am wearing a Vertical and Fenix 7 at the same time, and yesterday the Vertical counted 2200 more steps than the Fenix. Based on my activity level, the Fenix is definitely more accurate. Even after just waking up in the morning and making coffee I have according to the Vertical already made over 500 steps… NOT TRUE.

freeheeler

the step counter discussion is relatively old and my personal opinion, it is really not that important.
I know some people will not agree… but what do you want to know by the steps? what does it tell you?
fenix says x, suunto says y… what you can use the step counter for is to track how active or how lazy you are over time.
I find it much more important to track my fitness level, HRV and sleep duration.

Todd Danielczyk

@freeheeler HRV is a game changer for me. When Suunto turned that on for the Vertical I immediately (well after 14 days) saw the benefit to tracking that for sure!

@freeheeler said in Steep counter:

the step counter discussion is relatively old and my personal opinion, it is really not that important.
I know some people will not agree… but what do you want to know by the steps? what does it tell you?
fenix says x, suunto says y… what you can use the step counter for is to track how active or how lazy you are over time.
I find it much more important to track my fitness level, HRV and sleep duration.

The watch calculates calories burned based on the amount of steps… For many people, the daily calories spent is important. When you base one important metric on another metric that is completely unreliable, then you have garbage data. If it doesn’t work properly, just remove it or turn it off! Why include a stepcounter if it is garbage?

I understand you dont care. But many people do care. And when the product is advertised with a stepcounter that calculates calories spent based on the step counter, the stepcounter should be reliable, not hot garbage.

And if Suunto can’t get a basic thing like step counter somewhat reliable, then how can i trust ANY of the other metrics or data? … Do it right, or don’t do it at all!

pilleus

@freeheeler said in Steep counter:

my personal opinion, it is really not that important.

The question is not, if data which are captured by the 9PP or Vertical are important for me, but if these data are reliable.

The cyclist says: pedometer doesn’t have to be right, I’m cycling.
The kayaker says: GPS doesn’t have to be right, it measures the wrong speed on the river in the current anyway.
The sailor says: Altitude data doesn’t have to be correct, I’m only traveling at sea level.
The runner says: Calories don’t have to be right, I can’t eat as much as I consume.

Suunto offers widgets for all measured data on the watch and in the app. And I expect the data to be correct. Regardless of whether I need it or not.

And if these two watches differ greatly compared to other watches and to a pedometer, I don’t have to question the other watches and doubt their data. I simply have to make improvements.

That’s all that happened.

pilleus

@neonix said in Steep counter:

And if Suunto can’t get a basic thing like step counter somewhat reliable, then how can i trust ANY of the other metrics or data? … Do it right, or don’t do it at all!

Chapeau!

Zdeněk Hruška

@pilleus sorry but all of those examples you have provided are totally different to a step count issue. Suunto are outdoor / sports watch so I would argue their main purpose is to perform great measuring important stats for sports. If they fail in that purpose then yes it’s an issue. Step count isn’t important for any sport as far as I know. That’s why the gps is there for example and you want it to be precise, because it measures distance, that’s a good stat. Steps? It’s interesting to see how active you were that day. It doesn’t tell you anything more if you know the exact number. And burned calories are total guess for every watch and every device out there. It can’t be measured precisely. Again it’s there so you can see approximately the value of the calories you could burn. The exact number is wrong for different people no matter what.

freeheeler

@neonix
a company has a feature that someone isn’t convinced of its precision and hence all features are doubtful?
I’m surprised.

I don’t know how Suunto is estimating calories and I must say: I don’t check calories either…
is it differing between your devices as well?

wakarimasen

The curse of comparison! Which one is really correct, from all of the devices that are an estimation anyway?