Suunto Race 2 General Discussion
-
@brave_dave said in Suunto Race 2 General Discussion:
But reliable OHR is essential for daily HR and HRV information (sleep/rest) and therefore needs to accurately work.
Different users, different use cases. It was not my intention to criticize others, just to express my opinion and see how important is HR for others
I never use the watch to sleep, I have all metrics and readings related to health and training status disabled, or I’m simply not interested in them.
When I am tired or stressed I tend to know it. When I need more rest or recovery, I also tend to know it.
-
@Luis-Andés-Olmedo said in Suunto Race 2 General Discussion:
@brave_dave said in Suunto Race 2 General Discussion:
But reliable OHR is essential for daily HR and HRV information (sleep/rest) and therefore needs to accurately work.
Different users, different use cases. It was not my intention to criticize others, just to express my opinion and see how important is HR for others
I never use the watch to sleep, I have all metrics and readings related to health and training status disabled, or I’m simply not interested in them.
When I am tired or stressed I tend to know it. When I need more rest or recovery, I also tend to know it.
That said, I will probably go for the Race 2
-
@Luis-Andés-Olmedo I didn’t see it as a criticism, I just wanted to highlight that physiological values can be really important and that own perception can be totally wrong or useless sometimes. If you train on a high performance level for some years, you realize that sometimes you feel mentally exhausted or stressed but your body is ready. Other times you are totally motivated but your body needs rest or less training stress because you have an subtle or upcoming infection or motivation caused overreaching. If you learn to interpret these physiological values, they can really improve your training.
-
@brave_dave said in Suunto Race 2 General Discussion:
@Luis-Andés-Olmedo If you train on a high performance level for some years, you realize that sometimes you feel mentally exhausted or stressed but your body is ready. Other times you are totally motivated but your body needs rest or less training stress because you have an subtle or upcoming infection or motivation caused overreaching
I know :). After years of pace/feelings based training you also learn to detect those conditions. Sometimes you realize when you’ve already started the workout and need to adapt…
Maybe it is too old-style but for me having to pay attention to all of those metrics always increased my stress levels instead of helping me to train better.
But yes, I agree, if you base you training on HR, for sure it is important to have accurate readings. That is why I wrote “I sometimes wonder how many of Suunto/Garmin/Polar/Coros/etc users do really base their workouts on HR”.
I believe that many users want accurate HR only to have accurate HR, not because they really analyze and use the readings.
-
I do a variety of modalities: running, cycling, indoor rowing, gymnastics rings, yoga, dumbbells, kickboxing, etc. and one thing I look at is my overall time in HR zones across modalities. If HR is inaccurate, then it can throw these totals off. An early kickboxing session I did with Suunto averaged my HR as 155bpm while a Polar H10 strap had the session at 133bpm which is a major difference as my LT1 is about 144bpm. This convinced me I need to rely on my HR strap connected to the Suunto in many cases.
I also look at individual sessions. Here’s an example of where I am doing indoor rowing, and comparing my first interval (177w average) with the final working one (162w average) I can see different effects on my HR, and judge recovery of HR after intense intervals.
So it’s not just the “live” HR where I need accuracy but also in the reporting afterward.
-
@Luis-Andés-Olmedo i think HR is very important think. Almost all metrics like PTE, Calories, Recovery time, Fitnes level etc is based on HR. If this metric doesn’t work than everything i mentioned above is unusable. So if HR works everythink is great but if it doesn’t than only usable metric other than that is pace. Which can be measured by any cheap stopwatch if you are on known track. I understand that for running pace is really important. But in other sports like hiking, bike etc i think metrics like HR, cadence etc are more important.
-
@Tomas5 For now, when I need precise HR mesures (and I agree with you, it’s important), I use chest strap. Even if SR2 OHR seems better, I would probably continue to use HR strap anyway for running, cycling. I use OHR for my everyday mesure, sleep tracking, or tracking for walk, other sports.
But for running and all high intensity activies, I’ll continue to use chest strap until we have a OHR (or other way) to have perfectly reliable data.
Plus HR strap allows VFC mesure (zone sense).
So for me, OHR are getting better and that’s a good thing, but for now it’s a vain debate to hope to have perfect mesures with it.Suunto’s devices at home :
Vertical titanium solar
Suunto Race S
S9pp titanium sand
Suunto Wing
S9B titanium Ambassador edition, A3P, X6 -
@Luis-Andés-Olmedo Pace is meaningless in the mountains and HR not much better. I use RPE for training now complement with ZoneSense, which is a game changer for me. ZS is not a proxy for HR
-
@Brad_Olwin I mainly do rpe too, just checking my jr sometime for 90% of my training (ohr I don’t use belt that much)
When I do intervals (short or long) I put a belt but even this I use rpe
I quantify my load using foster and it works quite well, when I run I know what is my Hr and I use the watch as a confirmation
Btw and sorry for the off topic but did you know if there is a way to define an rpe in the suunto app after exercice was recorded? -
@Josaiplu I use feeling for that…how hard the workout was. I have been asking for private comments as well. Tags will work for this.
-
@Tieutieu hope they will one day start again sell shirts like this https://www.lepape.com/en/salomon-t-shirt-movesense-men-grey with movesence support. I have some issues wearing chest strap. This would be best alternative.
Suunto Ambit 2, Suunto 5
-
@Tomas5 I would buy one, too!
-
@Tomas5 said in Suunto Race 2 General Discussion:
@Tieutieu hope they will one day start again sell shirts like this https://www.lepape.com/en/salomon-t-shirt-movesense-men-grey with movesence support. I have some issues wearing chest strap. This would be best alternative.
Tony Stark, Iron Man suit
