Suunto app Forum Suunto Community Forum
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Register
    • Login

    Race 2: GPS, cadence and distance accuracy vs previous Suunto models

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Suunto Race 2
    85 Posts 20 Posters 26.0k Views 19 Watching
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • D
      duffman19 @wakarimasen
      last edited by

      @wakarimasen That is a good read (the first link), but it needs to be pointed out that it is from 2016. At this point, most of our devices have moved on from “recreational grade” to “mapping grade” since dual-band technology allows for accuracy to “tell us which side of the road we are on.”

      I’d agree with those who argue that it isn’t important to quibble bout a 1-2% discrepancy in distance. The issue being discussed here, though, is that there is a clear and repeatable difference in distance calculation between devices from the same company that one would think are all using the same technology and algorithms (which apparently they aren’t).

      Vertical Ti / S9PP Ti / S9P Ti

      W 1 Reply Last reply
      Reply Quote 2
      • W
        wakarimasen Gold Members @duffman19
        last edited by

        @duffman19 said in Race 2: GPS, cadence and distance accuracy vs previous Suunto models:

        @wakarimasen That is a good read (the first link), but it needs to be pointed out that it is from 2016. At this point, most of our devices have moved on from “recreational grade” to “mapping grade” since dual-band technology allows for accuracy to “tell us which side of the road we are on.”

        I’d agree with those who argue that it isn’t important to quibble bout a 1-2% discrepancy in distance. The issue being discussed here, though, is that there is a clear and repeatable difference in distance calculation between devices from the same company that one would think are all using the same technology and algorithms (which apparently they aren’t).

        I think we may be ‘agreeing violently.’ 🙂

        From my previous post:
        I guess it would be interesting to understand how the new watches calculate distance compared to the old ones. It seems that most devices tend to overestimate distances, and maybe some logic has been applied to try and reduce errors which occur due to this.

        Nevertheless, I would be very surprised to learn that ‘official’ mapping is carried out by someone wearing a Suunto, Garmin, Polar or Corus device, and declaring the data ‘accurate.’

        Suunto Race Titanium
        Suunto Ambit3 Peak
        Polar H10
        Polar OH1

        jjpazJ D 2 Replies Last reply
        Reply Quote 2
        • jjpazJ
          jjpaz Bronze Member @wakarimasen
          last edited by

          @wakarimasen Please, no “violence” here 😊

          The origin of the thread was “Have you noticed if the new hardware measures less distance in activities than the previous watches?”.
          Just a question, just a comparison between behaviors of different watches with “similar” hardware and software.
          The topic wasn’t (at least primarily) about discussing (or complaining about) GPS technology or professional map creation, although any information is welcomed to learn about it (Telecommunications Engineer here, I know some things about GPS technology 😂 ).

          Suunto Vertical Titanium Solar, Suunto Race 2 Ti & Suunto Wing.

          W 1 Reply Last reply
          Reply Quote 1
          • sky-runnerS
            sky-runner Platinum Member @wakarimasen
            last edited by

            @wakarimasen said in Race 2: GPS, cadence and distance accuracy vs previous Suunto models:

            An interesting read for all of those suffering GPS distance errors which equate to 1-2% of the total distance travelled.

            GPS mileage discrepancies

            That post is from 2016 when single band GPS was the only option and the accuracy was rather mediocre. Around 2022 there was a real breakthrough in GNSS accuracy, and now even cheap watches easily achieve 1 meter accuracy for a single position when using multi-system multi-band GNSS. A consistent bias of 0.5-1% in the distance measurement is no longer a random thing caused by GPS but a systemic error caused by the algorithm.

            Furthermore, as has been explained above, the actual GPS distance remains accurate. The bias is introduced in post-processing, likely when fusing accelerometer and gyroscope data with the GPS data. I bet there is no such bias when doing a cycling activity and it applies only to walking or running. I know that Garmin does a similar thing for walking and running. They want to continue measuring the distance when GPS reception is lost, for example when briefly going through a tunnel or under an overpass, or near tall buildings. So the sensor fusion is continuously performed and that may make the measured distance different from the GPS distance.

            Suunto: Ambit, Ambit 3 Peak, 9 Baro, Race S, Race Ti, Vertical 2 Ti
            Garmin: Forerunner 210, Forerunner 610, Fenix 6X, Fenix 7X Ti

            W MdzOttM 2 Replies Last reply
            Reply Quote 1
            • W
              wakarimasen Gold Members @jjpaz
              last edited by

              @jjpaz said in Race 2: GPS, cadence and distance accuracy vs previous Suunto models:

              @wakarimasen Please, no “violence” here 😊

              The origin of the thread was “Have you noticed if the new hardware measures less distance in activities than the previous watches?”.
              Just a question, just a comparison between behaviors of different watches with “similar” hardware and software.
              The topic wasn’t (at least primarily) about discussing (or complaining about) GPS technology or professional map creation, although any information is welcomed to learn about it (Telecommunications Engineer here, I know some things about GPS technology 😂 ).

              I bow to your greater GPS knowledge! As I mentioned, I’m wondering if Suunto have down something on the post processing side, to change the output from previous watches. The other point however, is that it’s not beyond the realms of possibility that this new data may actually be more correct than the previous one. This is the problem with comparing devices and not having an accurate reference.

              No violence from my side - just curiosity, with a hefty slice of realism 😉

              Suunto Race Titanium
              Suunto Ambit3 Peak
              Polar H10
              Polar OH1

              jjpazJ 1 Reply Last reply
              Reply Quote 0
              • W
                wakarimasen Gold Members @sky-runner
                last edited by

                @sky-runner said in Race 2: GPS, cadence and distance accuracy vs previous Suunto models:

                @wakarimasen said in Race 2: GPS, cadence and distance accuracy vs previous Suunto models:

                An interesting read for all of those suffering GPS distance errors which equate to 1-2% of the total distance travelled.

                GPS mileage discrepancies

                That post is from 2016 when single band GPS was the only option and the accuracy was rather mediocre. Around 2022 there was a real breakthrough in GNSS accuracy, and now even cheap watches easily achieve 1 meter accuracy for a single position when using multi-system multi-band GNSS. A consistent bias of 0.5-1% in the distance measurement is no longer a random thing caused by GPS but a systemic error caused by the algorithm.

                I know that Garmin does a similar thing for walking and running. They want to continue measuring the distance when GPS reception is lost, for example when briefly going through a tunnel or under an overpass, or near tall buildings. So the sensor fusion is continuously performed and that may make the measured distance different from the GPS distance.

                Yes indeed, this is referenced in the (old) article. Given the over estimation that has been prevalent in devices, I’m merely wondering if this is the reason that distances have been reduced - perhaps with the introduction of a new ‘correction’ factor.

                Suunto Race Titanium
                Suunto Ambit3 Peak
                Polar H10
                Polar OH1

                1 Reply Last reply
                Reply Quote 0
                • MdzOttM
                  MdzOtt @sky-runner
                  last edited by

                  @sky-runner said in Race 2: GPS, cadence and distance accuracy vs previous Suunto models:

                  bet there is no such bias when doing a cycling activity and it applies only to walking or running.

                  I think I reported very early in this thread that I didn’t notice any changes to the distance between S9B and Race 2 when biking (potentially<50 m on a 50 km ride, and this always varies from session to session).

                  R2
                  S9 Baro
                  SA on Android
                  Ambit 3 Peak
                  Ambit 2 Sapphire

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  Reply Quote 0
                  • D
                    duffman19 @wakarimasen
                    last edited by

                    @wakarimasen said in Race 2: GPS, cadence and distance accuracy vs previous Suunto models:

                    I think we may be ‘agreeing violently.’

                    Agreed! 😆

                    Nevertheless, I would be very surprised to learn that ‘official’ mapping is carried out by someone wearing a Suunto, Garmin, Polar or Corus device, and declaring the data ‘accurate.’

                    Only for OpenStreetMap 😉

                    I made an interesting observation a few years ago when testing the SV1’s different GNSS presets (Performance vs. Endurance vs. Ultra). It seems that, as the GNSS accuracy/signal/capabilities (whatever you want to call it) increases, the measured distance decreases. Makes sense as fewer errors mean straighter lines and less distance. So it could stand to reason that the newer watches have even more accuracy, therefore measure slightly less distance.

                    However, I think this goes against all the work and analysis that @jjpaz has provided us here. It clearly looks like new watches have a different algo. My money would be on it having something to do with battery savings for those big, bright screens.

                    Vertical Ti / S9PP Ti / S9P Ti

                    F 1 Reply Last reply
                    Reply Quote 1
                    • F
                      Finnjf @duffman19
                      last edited by

                      @duffman19 as a single data point, I have compared my multiple (two different Garmins, three different Coros, and three different Suuntos, one of them the Race 2) to my measuring wheel. All of them compare favourably except the Race 2, which measures short every time, in the error range we’ve talked about in this thread (usually closer to 0.5% and not as often up to 1.5%). My wheel is accurate (and technique with it is good), so from my perspective it is indeed that the Race 2 measures short, even with straight and flat lines. A great watch in many ways, one that seems to be a bit off where (imho) it matters most.

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      Reply Quote 2
                      • jjpazJ
                        jjpaz Bronze Member @wakarimasen
                        last edited by

                        @wakarimasen said in Race 2: GPS, cadence and distance accuracy vs previous Suunto models:

                        I bow to your greater GPS knowledge!

                        Uhmm, irony? 🤣

                        As I mentioned, I’m wondering if Suunto have down something on the post processing side, to change the output from previous watches. The other point however, is that it’s not beyond the realms of possibility that this new data may actually be more correct than the previous one. This is the problem with comparing devices and not having an accurate reference.

                        No violence from my side - just curiosity, with a hefty slice of realism 😉

                        I completely agree. I’m very realistic about the GPS capabilities of a device worn on the wrist. and I haven’t cuestioned the ‘absolute’ accuracy of the devices.
                        When I run ~10K I really don’t know if I’ve run 10,2km or 9,8km but I can compare numbers in different devices as a reference.

                        And that’s the point (and the title) of the topic: “relative accuracy vs previous Suunto models” because it seems that this concrete model has a “different calibration” that shows different measures (relatively to the other models of the same brand with similar recorded GPS data).
                        This is the origin of my curiosity, because comparison is not against Garmin, or Coros, or Polar, is against “brand brothers” which show different output information with similar recorded input information and I suposse that Suunto has his own references and tests to measure “accuracy” 😁

                        That said, I still use the Race 2 daily, I still use it in my activities, I’ve adjusted my “expectations” regarding pace (around 3-4 seconds per kilometer) and I enjoy it, and that’s it. 😊

                        Suunto Vertical Titanium Solar, Suunto Race 2 Ti & Suunto Wing.

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        Reply Quote 2
                        • G
                          Ger43
                          last edited by Ger43

                          Hi everyone, unfortunately, I’ll be returning the Race 2 due to this GPS issue. I continued to run more tests, even pairing it with a Garmin Edge 530 (in bycicle mode), and the result was the same…a loss of about 130-150 meters over 20 km.

                          At this point, however, I don’t want to make any more mistakes and am considering getting the Race 1, but I understand that the user @jjpaz comparisons don’t mention the Race 1, but rather the Race S and the Vertical.

                          Do you think it might have the same problem, or should I be okay with it?

                          I’d also be leaning toward the Vertical 2, but I’m worried it might have exactly the same behavior as the Race 2 in terms of distance loss.

                          Do you think the Race 1 is significantly behind the Race 2 in terms of technology?

                          I love the Suunto style and would like to stick with the brand.

                          Thanks to anyone who can help me.

                          F 1 Reply Last reply
                          Reply Quote 0
                          • F
                            Finnjf @Ger43
                            last edited by

                            @Ger43 I have a Race 1 (and Race 2)… the Race 1 has been great, with none of the distance loss / trimming of the Race 2. Lots of comparisons of features online, but from my practical experience, what I’m most concerned about is accurate ascent/descent, and accurate distance. The Race 1 is great in these regards.

                            1 Reply Last reply
                            Reply Quote 0
                            • jjpazJ jjpaz referenced this topic on
                            • jjpazJ jjpaz referenced this topic on
                            • G
                              Ger43
                              last edited by

                              Hello, Is there any news regarding the issue of the distance reduction for Race 2? Have there been any updates on this in the meantime?
                              Many thanks.

                              E EgikaE 2 Replies Last reply
                              Reply Quote 0
                              • E
                                elbee @Ger43
                                last edited by

                                According to some people in this thread, the newer algorithm is optimised to show nice tracks on strava, while the older algorithm is optimised to show raw data.

                                This is all due to sport gadgets bloggers. They like to judge gnss accuracy how wel the gpx snaps to the map (because that’s easy). If it snaps well, gnss is very good. If it deviates it is called very bad.

                                Sportwatch manufacturers just react how popular gadget bloggers judge their watches. And their users too. Quite a few freak out if their trail on strava isn’t 100% perfectly aligned to the map. I don’t expect sportwatch manufacturers to go back to a lesser smooth algorithm.

                                For me it’s simple. Distance doesn’t make that difference. If my long run is reported as 25.1k or 25.5k, it’s all fine. Most intervals I do is on a track, so distance is no problem (do have to say, my race s is quite accurate on a track, while not using trackmode. better than my previous forerunner 965 and way better than my forerunner 935, but again, that doesn’t matter at all on a track). And if I do a race, I have to run all the way to the finish, no matter what distance my watch reports.

                                Suunto t3c | Suunto Ambit 3 sport | Tomtom runner 2 | Garmin forerunner 935 | Garmin forerunner 965 | Suunto race s
                                Stryd | Bryton Gardia R300L | Polar H9 | Polar oh1+ | Wahoo bolt v2 | 4iiii precision 3

                                1 Reply Last reply
                                Reply Quote -1
                                • EgikaE
                                  Egika Platinum Member @Ger43
                                  last edited by Egika

                                  @Ger43 yes, the distance filter in Race 2 has been changed many months ago and so Race 2 is now yielding the same distance data as other Suunto watches.

                                  Check this thread: https://forum.suunto.com/post/193781

                                  t6, S6, Elementum Terra, Ambit 3 Sapphire, Spartan Ultra, Traverse Alpha, S7 Graphite LE, S9B Ambassador, S9P Titanium, S9PP Titanium, Vertical All Black, Race Titanium, Race S Titanium Courtney, Run Lime, Race 2, Vertical 2 Titanium, Race 3s

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  Reply Quote 1

                                  Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                  Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                  With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                  Register Login
                                  • First post
                                    Last post

                                  Suunto Terms | Privacy Policy