Unfortunately time to go back to Garmin.
-
@wmichi said in Unfortunately time to go back to Garmin.:
@Brad_Olwin You said, you get alerts with your structured workouts created in the Suunto app. Are you talking about production firmware? I have just tried it with my Suunto Race and I don’t get any audible alerts or vibrations when I am outside of the target HR range.
I am talking about the alerts that come with a change, for example in my Tempo 3x10 I had an alert to start, alert for recovery, etc. The S+ screen shows the target for the workout as red and green so easy to see. The OP did not specify target range alerts, I don’t need those and may not want them. I train more by RPE but use the target to see if I am near the range I intend to be.
-
@Kristin-Jensen said in Unfortunately time to go back to Garmin.:
@geolerigolo Yes you are correct, and i love the look and feel of the Suunto watches, but that is not enough when wanting to take your running seriously
Yes excatly, can’t wait. i have uploaded all my past Suunto activities to my Coros account and have already a full 100 km trainingprogram waiting on me in the Coros Traning Hub
I would be very concerned about loading a training program from a watch and use that to train for an ultra. No stock training plan can provide the appropriate stimuli at the correct time to ensure that you are training to your potential. AI might get us there but not yet since there is debate about using metrics. Besides, who wrote the plan? Does it take into account any of your strengths or weaknesses? Will it help you train mentally? Or help train your gut? I doubt it.
For example, HR in the opinion of many is a poor metric to use for training ultras. The races are so long that HR training is unlikely to achieve the goals you set, especially on longer runs.
Power is not useful either as the terrain and changes in what is under your feet alter power sufficiently it is not useful. Uphill is typically power hiking and downhill is eccentric contractions that power does not even measure.
Pace doesn’t help either.
I had a Garmin for 8 months while training for a 100 mile race. The suggested workouts were completely inadequate to prepare me to race.
I am nearly at 50 ultra races now, just my 2 cents worth. -
@maszop said in Unfortunately time to go back to Garmin.:
For me as a customer, all this mess and lack of transparency with updates is unacceptable. Especially since they concern many small bugs that should be released on an ongoing basis (if they are ready), without waiting for any major updates that the client has no idea about anyway.
As an example, I will use contour lines on the map, the absence of which is a very important element of maps for me. Developers assured that it was only a temporary removal due to some problems. Months pass and no one publicly discusses this topic. Will they come back? Will I be able to see a larger area on the screen? Does anyone even listen to customers?
I totally agree on this, even without a release date having the contour lines go away when you were using them without any hint of a change is not helpful. A general idea of when the update will come and an explanation for why the lines are gone along with enhancements would be helpful. I am 100% with you on this.
For small bugs including the ATL/CTL/TSS that affect some, perhaps the fix involves adding new major features. I think it would go a long way if Suunto was willing to state why the correction is not implemented quickly and give some idea what was coming without being absolutely specific.
This is an excellent example of where a little information might go a long way for some including @GiPFELKiND.
Vector/T6c/Ambit 3 Peak/S5 Copper/S3/S7 Ti/S9 baro Ti/S9P Ti/S9PP Ti/Vertical Ti/Race Ti/RaceS/Ocean/Wing
-
@Brad_Olwin said in Unfortunately time to go back to Garmin.:
@geolerigolo Too many times I hear the watch, the watch, the watch with virtually no one commenting on the entire ecosystem. How is the Coros app? Do they have incredible heat maps? Do routes in the map show climbs, descents, grades, etc? Are the training metrics universal as are Suunto metrics partnering with TrainingPeaks? I’ve used the Garmin Connect app and don’t care for it much.
Personally, I don’t think making a comparison only on the hardware is a good idea. Would I like structured workouts WITH ALERTS? Well, we already have those, I get alerts with my structured workouts created in the Suunto app, curious why you do not.
I have no issues with someone preferring another brand, I think it is short sided to simply compare the watches.
Would be good to see your problems on the watch and the basic features you are missing, the one you mentioned is not a problem unless you use a 3rd party to sync structured workouts. I would like alerts on my TP workouts but not a deal breaker.As for updates, Garmin does not publish new features they are planning. Do you know what is in the next update? I am not discussing the beta, but the next update after that, Garmin does not publish a roadmap, no different than Suunto. Does Coros?
I can’t find it now, but in the past Garmin had a presentation with which features would go each watches and “when” (not exact date).
Most of it, comming from Betas, but yeah I understand your point.To everyone that is raising their voice about lack of updates of visibility of Suunto, I can only talk about my experience, which, as most moderators share: learn to respect the company’s decision and if it doesn’t match your expectations, seek elsewhere.
From movescount fiasco for ambit users, to not quite find the S9P a watch that was worth its money for my use, I made a 100% switch to garmin (from low end devices as FR45 to 965, from etrex 30x to 1040 solar, scale, etc)
And honestly couldn’t be happier. Basic functions we had on movescount/ambits are present, and I find the support (both firmware and chat/warranty) better. Also, the full ecossystem works (not super neat, but works).
Does it make me a suunto hater now?
No. the app is amazing. I wish more brands put the effort on the app as suunto, and I still love the ambits, and older watches. The new watches continue to look stunning. But is it enough to put 400 or more euros in a Suunto watch when it gets out?
Not yet, first of all because I don’t need it…and for other reasons that me and others have written.
Maybe one day…does it worth to complain? I think not…life is too short to complain, enjoy your watch, and if it gets on your nerves, sell it. -
@André-Faria I mostly agree with you
As I have used different (most) ecosystems and as I would like Suunto to get better, I just shared my opinion on what could be improved and what I personally think are basic things like alerts when doing structured workouts. I consider it info the moderators can then tell to Suunto more directly than we can
Don’t worry, for me the watch is a tool and whatever running watch I have doesn’t change how I feel when I run. I enjoy the running experience, which has been improved with the Suunto Sonics which I find great and nice. I also sometimes run by RPE when I don’t really need any data ^^ -
@Brad_Olwin said in Unfortunately time to go back to Garmin.:.
This is an excellent example of where a little information might go a long way for some including @GiPFELKiND.
-
@cosme-costa said in Unfortunately time to go back to Garmin.:
small things that most of them is said that will be solved in the next update
Where I can read about next update? What they will fix?
-
@karmazynowycukiereczek nothing unified and official yet, but the Suunto devs and testers are writing here and there what is being worked on.
Updates for Suunto watch are coming on a quarterly update, so the next update should be around April.
From what is being gathered around the forum, its mostly bugfixes, Suunto is actively working on :- battery drain problem
- missing previous features like weekly recap
- 1 day offset in the CTL/HRV displayed on the watch vs the app (the watch being one day late)
- missing some texts/translation
- HR sensor turning off sometimes even while its active
- HR sensor turning on sometimes even while its deactivated
- probably many more
I dont’ say that all will be fixed, but these are the things on Suunto “todo” list, but i doubt they are all the same priority
-
@Elipsus since vertical solar announcement, I put my 2 cents on a sooner update !
Suunto’s devices at home :
Vertical titanium solar
Suunto Race S
S9pp titanium sand
Suunto Wing
S9B titanium Ambassador edition, A3P, X6 -
@robis basic functionality work - not enough for 400€ watch imho ;( the most annoying thing is - you don’t know when and what is going to fixed and no response from Suunto here on forum. I don’t think it’s so hard to have fix every month, especially for easy device as watch is.
-
@Tieutieu I had Garmin Epix2 and although I was part of the Beta programme and knew what they were up to, my issue with gained elevation was never fixed. The way Suunto handles elevation is a dream come true. While it would be nice to know the Roadmap of Suunto, I would not exchange it for boring design of Garmin (personal taste) and issues with basic measurements.
-
@thailon said in Unfortunately time to go back to Garmin.:
@robis basic functionality work - not enough for 400€ watch imho ;( the most annoying thing is - you don’t know when and what is going to fixed and no response from Suunto here on forum. I don’t think it’s so hard to have fix every month, especially for easy device as watch is.
believe it or not, if you were not the one to remind me that the watch needs a patch, I would keep on using it without realizing that it needs to be patched.
-
@vjakub I have also some problems with elevation outside of activities (but not during) with my Fenix 7x. But as soon as I have a GPS fix, which lasts about 10 seconds max, the altitude is good again.
I have a problem with altitude on my Race too, but if I want to use GPS to know my elevation, it takes wayyyy longer (around 10 minutes when it finds it).
As I’m not a developer, the question I keep asking myself is “why oh why, with similar watches (for example 100 Race or 100 Fenix) and with the exact same software, some people are having problems and others not?”
I don’t understand how it works. -
@geolerigolo said in Unfortunately time to go back to Garmin.:
but if I want to use GPS to know my elevation, it takes wayyyy longer (around 10 minutes when it finds it).
because Suunto algorythm (fusedalti) doesn’t take into account the very first GPS fixes data and is waiting these long minutes to ensure that GPS altitude is “good quality enough”.
As I’m not a developer, the question I keep asking myself is “why oh why, with similar watches (for example 100 Race or 100 Fenix) and with the exact same software, some people are having problems and others not?”
watch could be similar (and some can have any software bugs that other may not), but users and users environment are not : days are changing, positions are changing, GPS quality is even changing from days and positions, etc… All is influencing the final result.
Just to say that it is not so easy to compare. There could be global trends for sure, but to understand why oh why … -
@thailon agreed. Great watch but suunto seriously lacks updates. Monthly should be a minimum.
-
@landlord4714 Come on! Why not weekly or daily updates? Why they don’t open up the code and make it public source and then, we, the universal experts in everything, start coding and solve all the bugs and add the coolest features that nobody has thought about.
I think all of you should start cooling down your expectations, but not only here, in general, with updates and companies. In my experience Suunto delivers, the amount of updates (bug fixes and features) that the S9B has received can blow your mind if you look at it in perspective.
I have asked and continue to ask, honest question, which are the features that Suunto lacks or are buggy that makes you move to another brand? I’m curious to know what I would find in Garmin or Coros or … that will blow my mind and is a game changer (My Garmin 530 is not blowing my mind but maybe the watches are different)
Some small remarks:
- In a race, the only important parameter is TIME
- If somebody else has to do it, it always going to be easier than if I have to do it myself, so before saying that something is easy ask yourself how easy will be if you have to do it.
- Go out, train and stay healthy
-
@cosme-costa you and I have the same sentiment; thank you for saying what needed to be said.
-
@cosme-costa said in Unfortunately time to go back to Garmin.:
In a race, the only important parameter is TIME
Strictly speaking, our whole life is just time. And unlike a race, life should be a journey.
-
@cosme-costa Yes, I have the same opinion as you. It seems to me that some people rather spent time by complaining what their watch can’t do instead of going out and have a workout.
I understand that people want value for their money. But they can always read reviews before buying a new device. And they can return or sell a device if they aren’t satisfied. They can give it a bad review and spread it all over the social networks. Instead they are trolling on the forum “demanding” something basically for free.
But yeah I get it, training hurts but complaining on forums doesn’t…
Having said that I know there are bugs and things that could be improved regarding Suunto watch. But none of those things usually limit me during my day to day training or racing… -
@cosme-costa said in Unfortunately time to go back to Garmin.:
@landlord4714 Come on! Why not weekly or daily updates? Why they don’t open up the code and make it public source and then, we, the universal experts in everything, start coding and solve all the bugs and add the coolest features that nobody has thought about.
I think all of you should start cooling down your expectations, but not only here, in general, with updates and companies. In my experience Suunto delivers, the amount of updates (bug fixes and features) that the S9B has received can blow your mind if you look at it in perspective.
I have asked and continue to ask, honest question, which are the features that Suunto lacks or are buggy that makes you move to another brand? I’m curious to know what I would find in Garmin or Coros or … that will blow my mind and is a game changer (My Garmin 530 is not blowing my mind but maybe the watches are different)
Some small remarks:
- In a race, the only important parameter is TIME
- If somebody else has to do it, it always going to be easier than if I have to do it myself, so before saying that something is easy ask yourself how easy will be if you have to do it.
- Go out, train and stay healthy
Easy to answer, I use navigation a lot and I need at least names on a map, and preferably routable maps, Garmin has it and Suunto and others company don’t (except Polar which has names too but no routable maps, and maybe Apple but as I don’t use an Apple Watch I don’t know).
Another thing which is important to me is alerts during structured workouts as I don’t want to look at my watch all the time.
Third, freezes during a workout is quite annoying to me.
But if none of you uses these functionalities then it is a great watch for you. But as I said before, people on this forum who have been using Suunto watches for a long time don’t really like when others say that the watch is missing things for some people.
I think Suunto could use these “complaints” as you call them to get better, moreover I think people who have used watches from different companies have opinions that could give good indications. But if you don’t want to listen to it then don’t.
If I remember well, the Race has been marketed as a “performance” watch, which means it is also usable on roads and not only trails. And there when you want to run a marathon or else, time IS NOT the only important parameter. You also need pace and heart rate in my opinion, and preferably no freezes too.
