Feature Request: Native and Integrated LiveTrack for Suunto Race 2
-
Buenos días,
Solo quiero apoyar la iniciativa de campillo y aprovechar este hilo para que todo aquel usuario de suunto que eche de menos dicha función, la reclamé desde aquí. Me alegro de no ser el único que piense que dicha función de seguridad, tan necesaria en este tipo de dispositivos, deba estar integrada entre las funcionalidades del mismo y no depender de la app de un tercero, que personalmente no he conseguido que funcione. También quiero reclamar que la actualización Q2 sea implementada en Suunto Race y Vertical sin más demora. Suunto no puede dejar ya obsoletos a estos dispositivos. Un saludo a todos.
-
+1
I need LiveTrack feature but refuse to use the LiveTrack S+ app because of the reliability issues with the app and concerns that it might contribute to the watch instability.
When I owned a Garmin watch I used the LiveTrack regularly. Now I sometimes use Strava live tracking as an alternative.
One specific addition to the list of requirements above is to make it possible to configure the frequency of updates to conserve the phone battery, in particular when used during ultramarahons. It would be useful if whoever watches the tracking progress could see ETA for waypoints.
-
While live.t is working for me just as designed (last time a 110km bike ride with some stops and pauses), I still don’t get the advantage of this feature.
You need to carry your phone anyway. Why not just use a phone app that transmits your position. I am.sure there are apps that allow to show the live track against your route.
The only thing is you replace GPS on the phone (save power?) with BT (draw power)…
Am I missing things? -
You need to carry your phone anyway. Why not just use a phone app that transmits your position.
With live tracking, as requested, and as garmin implemented it, only the gnss of the watch is used. The phone isn’t using gnss. It receives the location from the watch.
There is a huge difference in battery usage on the phone between the requested feature and your way of using.
-
@Egika Phone queries GPS position every second. A well designed live tracking could transmit positions from the watch to the phone in bursts once every 30 seconds or perhaps even less frequently. That would save the phone battery compared to tracking on the phone.
Furthermore, integration with route tracking would be very valuable to not only show where the current position is but where it is on the planned route.
-
@sky-runner can a pure phone app not do the same? Capture position evety 30s and also hold a planned route?
As GNSS can be powered from a sport watch for many hours, the comparably much bigger phone battery should not really see the power load of it, I would think -
@elbee I understand the concept.
My point is, if GNSS on phone instead of BT really is such a big difference. If my Suunto can power GNSS für dozens of hours from the super small watch battery, the power consumption of GNSS should not stress a much larger phone natty a lot… -
can a pure phone app not do the same? Capture position evety 30s and also hold a planned route?
I anticipated you’d ask this question. The problem is that either the phone has to track GPS continuously or disable GPS radio and try to re-lock to GPS every 30 seconds. But locking to GPS when moving fast is challenging and may fail do it within 30 seconds, especially if the phone is stored deep in running pack.The accuracy would likely suffer significantly and at the end it probably wouldn’t save any battery at all because it would spend a lot of power re-locking to GPS. In particular, the distance coming from the phone would likely be quite wrong, especially if it obtained GPS positions infrequently. Now imagine someone tracking a runner during a race and getting wrong distances and trying to compare that to official race course splits between aid stations?
If you look at some apps that do live tracking, for example UTMB LiveTrail, there is an option to track every 4 minutes as you suggested, but in the case of LiveTrail the tracking is done during a race and a race course is known in advance (built into the app), so the tracking puts the runner on the course even if there was poor accuracy, and the distance tracking isn’t affected.
I think for general live tracking, taking positions from the watch is still better. There is already a BLE channel between the watch and the app, so sending a few bytes per second should not be a big deal.
-
@sky-runner ok, then track GPS position continuously and just transmit data every now and then.
Running GPS in the background should not draw too much energy (as mentioned in other post the watch with it’s super small battery can do so for days, so the effect of continuous GPS on a phone battery should be minimal). -
@Egika The main problem with tracking GPS on the phone is that the phone antenna is usually not positioned optimally for reception so the distance accuracy is usually poor. At longer distances a lot of distance discrepancy accumulates towards the end.
If a person who follows me want to know where exactly I am on a race course distance wise, they would be getting inaccurate information. I’ve seen cases where a phone distance can be 10-20% off.I already use Strava tracking, but it is certainly sub-optimal. In the future when I choose my next watch between Suunto and Coros, this will be one of the factors because Coros does provide live tracking natively.
-
not positioned optimally for reception so the distance accuracy is usually poor.
I don’t think accuracy is the best argument to convince someone live tracking via a watch is better. A follower really doesn’t need to know your position within centimetres.
Saving batterylife on your phone is quite important. Live tracking is a safety feature at first, and so is batterylife left on your phone in emergencies You want to preserve batterylife on a phone for when it counts, not waste it on something your watch is already doing.
An other argument. Live tracking should be easy to use and hard to forget to start.
As it is implemented on a garmin, it just starts when you start an activity. No hassle. No third party apps to remember to start. The followers get an email with a link to follow. No need to scan a qr code and keep the link for a long period of time.
-
@Egika this.
I wonder if the general feeling that positioning causes a big drain on phones is actually most people’s experience is navigating in a car and seeing battery plunge.
But its because the screen is on.
-
@Nigel-Taylor-0 very good point

-
Might be.
But that doesn’t solve the other issues, like easy to start live tracking (automatic when you start an activity on your watch, not having to start some other app) and not be able to see the course you plan to follow. And not have to share your data with yet an other company.
For now I use Apple’s find me function but I have to remember to enable and disable it. And when I bike, my wahoo just does live tracking how it supposed to work (just like my previous garmin watches), my wife get’s a notification email whenever I start an activity. No hassle, no need to remember it. It just works.
Third party app solutions aren’t a solution. Just a crapy sort of workaround.
-
The monitoring and creation itself is not a problem. The problem is what we don’t see, personal data protection, creating another data center, employees to manage, each country has different rules. Suunto may have a lot of improvements waiting to be approved. The main ones are those with patents.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login