Suunto Vertical: Bug Collection
-
Well, I think this is the end of the Suunto adventure for me. After using a Race and its unreliable HR sensor, I ordered a vertical.
I’ve been wearing the watch for 72 hours and I’m experiencing the same problems with the heart sensor but on top of that, there are stability problems (2 crashes), and totally fanciful step detection! I spent the morning sitting at my desk and the watch counted 2000 steps, an incredible heart rate. This data being integrated into the recovery algorithms, resources, etc. Everything that results from this will turn out to be false in the end.
Even if I love the design, the comfort of the watch, the simplicity of the application, putting 6/800 euros into a tool dedicated to helping athletes who are not reliable, I am not ready.
I might come back if this is all made reliable.
-
@Fizzgig You do seem to have bad luck…
I wear my SV all the time, and whilst the step counter is a bit ‘optimistic’, it is not so different to my Ambit, or my Coros Apex Pro, and I can still compare day to day what my activity level is.
The OHR, on the other hand, is very reliable for 24/7 operation (for me), and sleep tracking is ‘close enough’ for it to reflect how I feel about my sleep (although last night I was awake more than it thought, which is unusual for both of us!). I accept that maybe Suunto wrist OHR is not the best on the market, but it continues to be sufficiently reliable for me.
Different strokes for different folks…
-
@Fizzgig Same for me: the OHR is often delirious, with resting data 2 times higher than normal. similarly, when I walk, the cardio goes up to 120 pulses, even though I’m not jogging… I’m hoping for a rapid software update on this subject.
-
I’ve been comparing my Race with my Vertical and it seems like I’m more likely to see the spurious readings with the Race. Now, is it how it rests on my wrist differently or is the firmware any different? Hard to say.
But I know that sitting at my desk and glancing at my Race and seeing my heart rate at 120 bpm is very disconcerting. Switching watches with a Fenix 7x, a much bulkier watch, never shows that.
-
Yes clearly! Especially since all the data collected is used for algorithm calculations. I’m coming out of a day at the office with a site visit this afternoon with 6810 steps. 3500 this morning while sitting from 8 a.m. to 12 p.m. (with a passage through the coffee machine which is 25 meters from my office…) Even when washing my hands, the simple act of moving the handle, the watch counts 190 steps and a heart rate between 90 and 110 bpm.
I stopped and restarted my watch to see if that would fix the problem, nope. I find myself with higher resource data than before the shutdown, a lower TSB and CTL as well (certainly the update of day -1 data)
I don’t have a very high sporting level ( 36:30 in 10km and 1h24 in half marathon but all the data displayed in the application are absolutely false.The only correct data are: sleep time, time, pressure and altimetry.
Quite frankly, I expected much better from a Suunto watch. I was ready to make some concessions but this is too much!
-
@Fizzgig yesssss hope for update to solve the OHR Problems… Please Suunto implement a better OHR Sensor!
-
@Fizzgig said in Suunto Vertical: Bug Collection:
I don’t have a very high sporting level ( 36:30 in 10km and 1h24 in half marathon but all the data displayed in the application are absolutely false.
Curious on your definition of “high sporting level” given those times
-
I’m 45 this year and I don’t consider myself ultra sporty. I have been cycling for 15 years and running for 3 years.
Before smoking 2 packs of cigarettes per dayThat being said, this doesn’t help my issues with Suunto watches. I tried garmin and coros before coming here and never had a single bug or crash. The values (although to be taken lightly) seemed more reliable to me. I don’t need all the gadgets offered by competitors. I don’t even use call or text notifications. I just need to have sleep monitoring data (I have a little sleep apnea), heart monitoring and I like to know the average number of steps I take per day.
-
@Fizzgig said in Suunto Vertical: Bug Collection:
stromdiddily
J’ai 45 ans cette année et je ne me considère pas comme ultra sportif. Je fais du vélo depuis 15 ans et je cours depuis 3 ans.
Avant de fumer 2 paquets de cigarettes par jourThat being said, this doesn’t help my issues with Suunto watches. I tried garmin and coros before coming here and never had a single bug or crash. The values (although to be taken lightly) seemed more reliable to me. I don’t need all the gadgets offered by competitors. I don’t even use call or text notifications. I just need to have sleep monitoring data (I have a little sleep apnea), heart monitoring and I like to know the average number of steps I take per day.
Non tu n’as pas compris, les montres de Suunto visent les sportifs qui courent à 13min/km, 16min/km pour 100 miles
. Si tu suis un les testeurs de Suunto tu peux remarquer cela.Quand je compare les montres, les montres Suunto proposent des valeurs précises quand je marche,
Quand je cours au delà de 4min/km, là c’est un pure bordel de merde.
-
@zhang965 sérieusement…
mode humour I Guess…?? -
nope, it’s mode troll as usual
there’s no more humor, if ever been, in his posts since a long time
he’s the only one enjoying this trolling by now -
@zhang965 said in Suunto Vertical: Bug Collection:
@Fizzgig said in Suunto Vertical: Bug Collection:
stromdiddily
J’ai 45 ans cette année et je ne me considère pas comme ultra sportif. Je fais du vélo depuis 15 ans et je cours depuis 3 ans.
Avant de fumer 2 paquets de cigarettes par jourThat being said, this doesn’t help my issues with Suunto watches. I tried garmin and coros before coming here and never had a single bug or crash. The values (although to be taken lightly) seemed more reliable to me. I don’t need all the gadgets offered by competitors. I don’t even use call or text notifications. I just need to have sleep monitoring data (I have a little sleep apnea), heart monitoring and I like to know the average number of steps I take per day.
Non tu n’as pas compris, les montres de Suunto visent les sportifs qui courent à 13min/km, 16min/km pour 100 miles
. Si tu suis un les testeurs de Suunto tu peux remarquer cela.Quand je compare les montres, les montres Suunto proposent des valeurs précises quand je marche,
Quand je cours au delà de 4min/km, là c’est un pure bordel de merde.
Clearly you are an awesome athlete @zhang965, you could certainly give that Courtney Dewalter a run for her money. She only managed 16min/km at her last win of Hardrock 100. You should sign up @zhang965 and show her what a real althete is!
-
@Fizzgig I wish you did not have this issue, I have never experienced erratic HR readings while sitting, driving, walking, etc with any of my Suunto watches. I see why this is an issue for you.
-
Clock alarm didn’t wake me up this morning. Don’t know if it’s related, but I’ve been draining my battery since the last sw update (and it’s been going down suspiciously fast) and it was showing 8% when my wife woke me up. But whatever the reason is my everyday 6:40 AM alarm didn’t go off.
Anyone else noticed the alarm not being reliable or if there is a relation to low battery?
EDIT: Actually right now at 7:50 AM I saw an alarm, but vibration was missing! So the alarm may have been showing at 6:40 under my pillow, but I’d say a silent alarm is pretty damn useless
-
What is your problem with this forum? I haven’t been here for long but I see that each of your interventions can mean anything! Did you have a bad experience?
Thanks Brad, I hope so too but I don’t see how I can fix this. I tried a lot of things… Tighten the bracelet more (with a nice red mark at the end of the day), wear it higher, shave the part of skin in contact with the sensor to see if my hair was not a problem. obstacle to reading. I know that the sensors on the arm are reliable on some people and others not. I can understand. But why is the step counting not up to par?
To be completely honest, it’s in the return box but I wonder if I’m not doing something stupid. Maybe an update is planned? I really like the watch (the object), the way it is made, the image of Suunto but all these problems prevent me from using it correctly (for what I want to do with it) -
I seem to have read somewhere that the watch goes into emergy saving mode below 10%. If this is the case, I think it’s normal (no bop, no tacticle, no OHR, no vibrator, etc…
-
@BrunoH This situation occurred when the charge was below 13% with the previous SV (replaced under warranty for another reason), and this is what happens with the new SV. The vibration stops working when the charge is below 13%, I do not use sound, but if I turn on the sound, the notification will work. And this is not an energy saving mode, because only vibration does not work. Now I have 10% and I miss all notifications. This is an obvious bug that was in the previous version of the software and also exists in the new one. I hope the Suunto team is aware of this issue and will fix it in future versions.
-
@BrunoH yes this works as designed. When the battery is less than 10% (I think), the vibration is disabled. Happened to me a few times and I overslept, but it’s like that.
-
As far as I remember, it used to be 2%. At the same time, the daily HR worked accurately. I’ll try to check these points during the next discharge)) -
@Fizzgig said in Suunto Vertical: Bug Collection:
Thanks Brad, I hope so too but I don’t see how I can fix this. I tried a lot of things… Tighten the bracelet more (with a nice red mark at the end of the day), wear it higher, shave the part of skin in contact with the sensor to see if my hair was not a problem. obstacle to reading. I know that the sensors on the arm are reliable on some people and others not. I can understand. But why is the step counting not up to par?
To be completely honest, it’s in the return box but I wonder if I’m not doing something stupid. Maybe an update is planned? I really like the watch (the object), the way it is made, the image of Suunto but all these problems prevent me from using it correctly (for what I want to do with it)I wish I could help here, a couple others have seen this as well @GiPFELKiND being one of them. There are occasional updates to the OHR firmware but I have no idea if a new one is coming.
The step counting is another issue, on the high end watches Suunto does not have the same step counting algorithm as on the S5Peak. The thought being those that are using these watches are not as concerned about steps. That includes me, I have the widget deleted and if I could remove the step information from my Suunto App I would, I just have no use for it and don’t care. I realize others do.
I think the OHR issue is obviously a serious one as a lot of information is calculated from those data.