Disappointing Sleep tracking after new update
-
@Jeffrey-Tillack Sell the Ultra, but wait until Apple pauses sales. I got rid of mine. Love the smartwatch part but just not good enough for sport use. Should easily cover the cost of a Solar Vertical!
-
@Brad_Olwin have answered that a little higher up. Have been testing some various HR and have everything on.
However, after the new update the watch have been spot-on -
I’m running 2.30.38. I typically wake several times during the night. I’ve noticed that the watch will track one or two segments of sleep per day only. It doesn’t track more than two segments of sleep per day. As an example, let’s say I had:
Day 1:
2200-2315
2315-
Day 2:
-0100
0115-0350
0400-05301002-2310
2314-
Day 3:
-0015
0030-0200
0205-0350
0400-0533The watch might record:
Day 1: 2200-2315
Day 2: 0400-0530, 1002-2310
Day 3: 0205-0350It never tracks more than one segment per day, per sleep session. I hope this is clear.
Edit: changed firmware to 2.30.38
-
@DrSilverthorn This is old firmware, you should update to the newest firmware.
-
@Iggge Excellent
-
@Brad_Olwin My mistake. I am using the latest firmware. Corrected in original post.
-
Third night with the new update, and again my Vertical shows correct sleep analysis.
This is really good news! Good job Suunto!
-
@DrSilverthorn This seems to be similar to what I’m occassionally experiencing with mine. The days I sleep like a rock are accurately tracked started to end (though rarely any awake time). The days where I toss/turn or get up during the night, it’s either reporting a segment, as you describe, or random-seeming times.
-
I performed another hard reset ca. a week back and calibrated the OHR by getting a variety of (3-5 HR zone) activities in early. In combination with the update, more days were tracked accurately or accurately enough.
However, it still seems too unstable. Average sleep time is up 1h from before the update, so that’s an improvement, but it remains under the 6h average it should roughly be (and has previously steadily been since the Vertical’s release).
For what it’s worth, the last 7 days in review:
- F: Spot on. (07:47h)
- S: Nowhere close. (00:59h, 01:47 - 02:47 and no awake time, versus expected 5-6h with up to 1h awake time)
- S: Close enough. (04:59h, ca. 30m early on the wake up time)
- M: Close enough. (07:38h, guaranteed to have been awake, but no awake time tracked)
- T: Spot on. (05:16h)
- W: Not quite. (05:21h, wake up time stated to be 06:08, but overslept til nearly 08:30; did not get up at 06:08, no gaps or spikes in HR data)
- T: Nowhere close. (00:53h, 01:31 - 02:24, yet I went to bed at 22:30, passed out rather quick, and got up at 04:08. There’s a gap in the HR tracking and that always seems to throw off the algorithm entirely; did have the watch strapped properly)
Min. HR rate has been 46 on average. HR while writing this message on the sofa is 55-62. Resting HR set to 60 since last hard reset.
-
@AnonVerticalOwner Question : was that the first display you had when you woke up ? Didn’t the watch (and SA) got your sleep time updated a few time after ?
Let me explain :
last night I felt asleep at 10:22 pm and got awake to have a drink (for those who may ask : water only
) about one hour later. I then got asleep again until 7:24 am this morning.The first display when I woke up was my first one hour sleep period. But few minutes after my sleep time has been updated to 9:08 hours sleep, including 4 minutes awaken.
Every time I have such “awake” period at night, the watch behaviour is this same way.
Well, for me sleep tracking works really better since update. Before those kind of sleep/awake/sleep again period were not always tracked very well.
-
@AnonVerticalOwner
Great analysis! I have much, much better results since the update as well! My sleep summary also pops-up straight after I dismiss the alarm as it, previous to the ‘bigger 2.3’ update, was. I’ve had 2 nights of less exact data: what I found out is that a tight strap is key (I saw you mentioning this factor on your last record). Otherwise a BIG improvement on my end!
I also did a hard reset last week as I was experiencing fast battery drainage (full battery lasting me 3-4 days max without ‘specific’ usage). I recalibrated the % while updating the watch (charge to 100% from 12&%) and now it’s the first time in 5 weeks that I own the watch that battery consumption is aligned
[Consumption: roughly 8% / day under ‘normal’ use] -
This night i got 6 hours of sleep, thats “wrong” with about 40 min. That’s 100% acceptable for me so I am really happy with this new update.
I have resting HR at 60 and my sleeping window is between 2300-0800.
This night i went to bed late, and was asleep around 0130. The watch got this 40 min late, otherwise it was spot-on.Altso my steps are better after the update. When I woke up the watch shows 23 steps.
Before the update sometimes the watch said I had been walking around 500 steps during the night.So again! 2.30.38 update was awsome!
-
I concur that sleep tracking seems to be more accurate since the update. I couldn’t say ‘exact’, but then I am very good at lying quite still whilst reading, early in the morning, which my SV often thinks is still sleeping, but I accept that!
-
@Tieutieu Sadly hasn’t been the case! The 0:53h and 0:59h days are the final values (edit: the others too)*, and the “good morning” screen seemed to have happened during the night already on those days. I do experience what you’re describing on occasion, though. It’s great when it catches those scenarios and updates the values!
@RaDeck Good to hear!
Whether it’s due to 2.30.38 or just the calibration catching up, last night was spot on again — progress, progress.
-
@Brad_Olwin I have misgivings about buying the Ultra for sure. But for everyday life in a city it actually has proved worthy. And now that I’ve been diagnosed with a heart condition it probably is going to earn its purchase one day.
But yes, I think next year at some stage there’s a Vertical or a Race in my future.
Oh and the Ultra is crap at sleep… every day it’s way out. Yet my old Baro faithfully gets it right day after day!
-
Must say that since the latest fix my sleep tracking has been quite accurate, some discrepancies mostly under 30 minutes which is an enormous improvement to pre fix date.
-
A update
Last two days my watch have failed with my sleep recording.
My sleep windows is same as before (23-08) but my watch is only recording 3:14 h of sleep.Have gone to my bed sometime after 23 and I think that is where the problem is.
Yesterday I went to bed late at 01 and slept untli 08. Watch startat recording my sleep at 03 untlig 06.
To bad because last week it nailed every night and because of that all other data was correct to.
-
@Iggge I’ve got the newest sw version, but still I am getting absolutely ridiculous results every night. The falling asleep and waking up times are decent, but for some reason I’ve been supposedly awake for 2-3 hours every night. Which is false by the way.
It would be nice to know if it can be improved by tweaking the rest HR (I’ve seen contradicting opinions here in the forum). Or I’d like to see more detailed analysis of when does SV think I am awake? Does it confuse light sleep cycles as being awake or is there one continuos “awake” period?
-
@BrunoH The sleep/awake times have settled for me now too, but curiously enough I also still notice the issue you’re describing. Awake hours are also often round numbers, 1:00, 2:00, etc. Yesterday it was 2:00, while I slept like a rock and my HR was steady at the mid-forties throughout, no spikes.
Comms on resting HR rate seem contradicting, but Suunto customer service once instructed me to set the minimum HR at the daytime rest rate, and adjust it down as/if needed. In addition, they mentioned it’s important to ensure the accelerometer has solid data to calibrate on, as movement too is used for calculating sleep data. The accelerometer is (at least in part) calibrated through walking/running activities with GPS on. It might be that part of the equation is messing with the awake time, but it’s indeed guesswork for us
-
@AnonVerticalOwner hey I have some really good Infos about the physiology from our sleep. If you understand how exactly the Phases are perhaps you can find Out if the Suunto Algorithmus is working good or bad. Awake Times during our sleep is normal… Read it here
https://www.resmed-healthcare.de/patienten/die-schlafphasen-des-menschen
